Food Law News - UK - 1997

16 September 1997: PESTICIDE RESIDUES - Surveillance Issues

MAFF News Releases (260/261), 16 September 1997

Pesticide Residues

a) Surveillance results show responsible use of pesticides

Surveillance results from 1996 show responsible use of pesticides for food production in the UK.

The surveillance programme, carried out by the Working Party on Pesticide Residues (WPPR), covers the main food groups and also incorporates comprehensive diet studies to estimate overall human dietary exposure to pesticides.

Professor Ian Shaw, Chairman of the WPPR, said:

"The WPPR's surveillance programme has been operating since 1977. Increasingly, we have seen evidence that where pesticide residues are present in the diet, they are virtually always at low, safe levels. From a variety of 3,400 samples of foodstuffs analysed last year, results show that 66 per cent showed no detectable residues, 34 per cent had residues below the maximum residue level (MRL), and less than one per cent were found to have levels above MRLs. As analytical techniques become more sensitive we must expect to find more residues, albeit at very low levels. They have probably always been there, but it is only as techniques develop that they are being found.

"While the results show that consumers would not be at risk from the MRL exceedance, any findings of levels of pesticides above the MRL are investigated to ensure growers follow the rules set out to ensure that consumers can be confident in the safety of the food they buy."

The results are found in the Working Party on Pesticide Residues Report for 1996 published today, and available free of charge. The report also contains a questionnaire seeking the views of readers on how the presentation of these important results can be further improved.

The key findings of the 1995 report are as follows:

• milk - this report includes monitoring carried out following the findings in 1995 that 9 of the 216 samples of milk analysed exceeded the MRL for lindane (gamma-HCH). The 1996 results indicated that, although there were some fluctuations of residue levels during the year, there were no MRL exceedances. The report also summarises the action that was taken to investigate possible causes of the 1995 residues;
• organophosphorus (OP) residues in carrots - following the monitoring results on variability of OP residues between individual carrots reported in the Working Party's 1994 and 1995 report, further monitoring (on imported carrots) has been included in the 1996 report. These results were first published in a Pesticides Safety Directorate briefing note in July 1996 and indicate a lower level and incidence of residues than that found in UK carrots; when calculated on a composite basis only two of 22 samples contained residues and these were at levels well within the MRL. Further monitoring is in progress to confirm the position;
• UK winter lettuce - Working Party surveillance has consistently revealed evidence of misuse of pesticides on UK winter lettuce in recent years. The 1996 report includes three winter lettuce surveys - retail surveillance; wholesale surveillance; and EU surveillance. Further evidence of misuse has been revealed but at a reduced level. Enforcement programmes to date have resulted in three successful prosecutions and seven warning letters. An enhanced enforcement programme is planned for 1997/98.

b) More enforcement of Pesticide Residues

MAFF's commitment to ensure safe use of pesticides was given a boost today as Food Safety Minister Jeff Rooker announced an extended residue enforcement programme.

Jeff Rooker said:

"I am determined to ensure that growers follow the rules for safe food production, and this includes keeping control over pesticide residues in our food. The results of our pesticide residues in food surveillance show that a small problem with residue levels in lettuce has persisted. I am therefore expanding enforcement in order to guard against any further misuse of pesticides. We have already successfully prosecuted three growers for misuse, and will continue to take strong action if a grower is found negligent."

The new enforcement programme will concentrate on winter lettuce, as a result of earlier programmes which discovered misuse of particular fungicides. Because of these earlier programmes, the negligent growers were prosecuted for using a product (vinclozolin) which is not approved for use on UK lettuce. Seven other growers have been sent warning letters as a result of misuse.

The level of residues detected, in all cases, were not a concern in terms of consumer health. Use of this non-approved product could, however, have jeopardised the health of those applying the pesticide.

The Working Party on Pesticide Residues (WPPR) is responsible for the Government's surveillance programme on pesticide residues in food and animal feedingstuffs

The following notes are added to the News Release:

• The extended enforcement programme will cover all of the MAFF regions and up to 102 growers will be visited.
• In order to ensure compliance with the statutory Maximum Residue Levels (MRLs) samples will be obtained from grower's packing houses after harvest, in addition to the samples specified to be collected from grower's glasshouses before harvest. Samples will be taken from the premises where they are grown to maintain their traceability.
• The further enforcement programme will be carried out for the 1997/98 season. Other enforcement programmes were carried out in 1994/95, 1995/96, and 1996/97.
• Samples will be sent for analysis to the Central Science Laboratory in York.
• The Working Party on Pesticide Residues was established in 1977 to co-ordinate the monitoring of pesticide residues in food and animal feed, in human tissues and in wildlife and the environment. The WPPR reports to the independent Advisory Committee on Pesticides and the Food Advisory Committee.
• Maximum residue limit is the maximum concentration of a pesticide residue legally permitted in or on food commodities and animal feeds.